Legionella in Blocks of Flats: Who Is Responsible?
In a block of flats, the legionella duty sits with whoever controls the water system. The contract should say who that is. HSE guidance says a management contract "should clearly specify who has responsibility for maintenance and safety checks, including managing the risk from legionella".
In practice the freeholder or managing agent looks after the shared tanks, pumps and pipes. Each flat's owner looks after the water inside the flat. This page sets out the arrangements the HSE describes, and what to do when the paperwork is silent.
Managing a block? A fixed price for its shared water system within one working day.
Who holds the duty, at a glance
| The arrangement | Who holds the duty | Where |
|---|---|---|
| The agreement gives the owner the whole building | The owner | HSG274 Part 2, 2.149 |
| The owner keeps the common parts; leaseholders keep their flats | Shared between them | HSG274 Part 2, 2.149 |
| Responsibilities are passed to a managing agent | The agent, as far as the contract says | HSG274 Part 2, 2.149 |
| No agreement, or it does not say | Whoever controls the premises, or that part | HSG274 Part 2, 2.150 |
Why there can be more than one duty holder
The duty follows control. HSE guidance says those in control "have a responsibility to those who are not their employees, but who use those premises". In a block, that means residents, visitors and contractors.
A block rarely has one person in control of everything. The HSE says "it is increasingly common for there to be several dutyholders in one building". Each has the duty for the part they control.
It then describes how the duty can be divided. In a building with several occupiers there are three arrangements:
- "the owner takes on the full duty for the whole building"
- "the owner takes responsibility for the common parts while the leaseholders take responsibility for the parts they occupy"
- "there may be an agreement to pass the responsibilities to a managing agent"
And where the paperwork does not settle it: "the duty is placed on whoever has control of the premises, or part of the premises".
The HSE's own example
HSE guidance gives a worked example. A managing agent looks after a building and supplies hot and cold water to three tenanted areas. The line is drawn where the water crosses into each tenant's part.
- The managing agent is responsible "from the incoming mains up to where the water enters the part of the building the tenant occupies".
- Each tenant is responsible "from the point at which it enters their premises".
The example is a commercial building, but a block of flats is usually divided the same way. The shared system runs up to each front door, and the flat's own water lies beyond it.
The HSE adds a warning that matters to every managing agent. A tenant's contaminated system "may act as a reservoir, seeding it back down into the systems for which the managing agent has responsibility". So it says the agent should take steps, by contract, to see that tenants meet their duties too.
Inside the flats
Some flats have their own boiler and take cold water straight from the main. The water inside those flats is not part of the shared system. It is the flat owner's.
Where a flat is let, its landlord has a duty of their own. The HSE says landlords "have a legal duty to ensure that the risk of exposure of tenants to legionella is properly assessed and controlled".
That is a job for the flat's landlord, not the block. For a let house or flat there is DwellFlow. It is a legionella risk assessment for rented homes that the landlord carries out on a phone, with the report written by AI.
Where the block's plant feeds hot water into every flat, the shared system does not stop at the front door. The assessor will need to see inside a sample of flats, so tell residents before the visit.
Many similar flats: where to start
A housing association or council may control hundreds of similar homes. HSE guidance accepts that assessing every one at once may be impractical.
It says "a representative proportion of the premises for which they have responsibility should initially be assessed". The sample is chosen "on the basis of similar design, size, age and water supply". The rest follow, "eventually assessed on a rolling programme of work".
Getting into occupied homes is the usual obstacle. The HSE suggests checks can be made "when undertaking mandatory visits such as gas safety checks or routine maintenance visits".
Owner, agent and occupiers have to cooperate
Where employers share a building, the law goes further than each minding their own part. HSE guidance points to the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, regulation 11. It "requires that they cooperate with each other to ensure their respective obligations are met".
Its example is monitoring. One party's routine checks may show a problem in the building's water. That should be passed on, so that "a joint plan can be formulated and appropriate remedial action taken".
For a block, the practical version is simple. Whoever takes the temperatures tells whoever owns the plant, in writing, the same week.
What the management contract should settle
The HSE says the contract should specify who is responsible. It does not give a list. From the questions that cause arguments later, a contract or lease should answer these:
- Who commissions the risk assessment, and who decides when it is reviewed.
- Who is the named responsible person for the shared system, with a deputy.
- Who does the routine checks: temperatures, flushing little-used outlets, tank inspections.
- Who keeps the records, and who can see them.
- Who pays for remedial work the assessment recommends, and how quickly it is done.
- How access to flats is arranged where the shared system runs into them.
- Who tells residents what they need to know, and when.
The routine checks can be supplied as a service: see legionella monitoring. What a duty holder has to do is set out on your legionella responsibilities.
For blocks of flats with shared water systems · City & Guilds qualified, LCA registered assessors
Questions people ask
Who is responsible for legionella in a block of flats?
Whoever controls the water system. HSE guidance describes the owner taking the whole building, or only "the common parts", or passing the duty to a managing agent by contract.
Is the managing agent the duty holder?
Only as far as the contract says. HSE guidance says the management contract "should clearly specify who has responsibility for maintenance and safety checks, including managing the risk from legionella". Read yours before assuming either way.
The lease says nothing about legionella. Who has the duty?
Whoever is in control. Where an agreement is silent, the HSE says "the duty is placed on whoever has control of the premises, or part of the premises". For the shared system that is usually the freeholder or its agent.
Does a block of flats need a legionella risk assessment?
Yes. The HSE says: "All water systems require a risk assessment but not all systems require elaborate control measures". A block's shared tanks, pumps and plant are assessed like any workplace system, by a professional.
Do we have to assess every flat?
Not always at once. For landlords with many similar homes, HSE guidance says "a representative proportion" should be assessed first, with the rest on a rolling programme. A leaseholder's own flat, with its own boiler, is the leaseholder's.
Who is responsible for the water inside a flat?
Usually the flat's owner, where the flat has its own boiler and mains-fed cold water. If the flat is let, its landlord has the duty for it. Where the block's plant feeds hot water into the flats, the shared system reaches inside them.
How often should a block's legionella risk assessment be reviewed?
Whenever something changes: new plant, a change of managing agent, flats standing empty, or checks that show the controls are not working. No fixed period is set in legislation.
Sources
- HSE, HSG274 Part 2: The control of legionella bacteria in hot and cold water systems, paragraphs 2.138 to 2.151 and Info box 2.8 (Example of shared premises and responsibilities)
- HSE, ACOP L8: The control of legionella bacteria in water systems (fourth edition, 2013)
- HSE, Legionnaires' disease: your duties
This guide explains legionella legislation and HSE guidance in plain English. It is not legal advice.
Related
Your fixed price. Six questions from here.
Carried out by our City & Guilds qualified, LCA registered risk assessors.